Case Summaries

3984 A candidate or former candidate for political office is a public figure, and in an action for defamation, must plead "actual malice" (i.e., knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for truth), and general allegations of malice do not satisfy that requirement; calling plaintiffs "top rated dumb asses" and linking their names to a website titled satan.com do not assert facts and so cannot support an action for defamation; falsity of the statement that plaintiff is a deadbeat dad who owes his wife and children thousands is not sufficiently alleged by the plaintiff's declaration that he does not owe his wife and children thousands; falsity of the statement that plaintiff is bankrupt is not sufficiently alleged by the plaintiff's declaration that he is not bankrupt coupled with his admission that he filed a petition in bankruptcy; falsity of a statement that plaintiff is a drunk is not sufficiently alleged by the plaintiff's declaration that he is not an alcoholic; for those reasons, plaintiffs' declarations do not sufficient allege the falsity of any statement made by linking plaintiffs' names to websites titled olddrunk.com, and bankruptasshole.com; the statement that plaintiff is "chewin' tobaccy" is probably too whimsical for the reasonable person to take seriously, does not carry sufficient opprobrium to be defamatory even if it is false, and is not sufficiently alleged to be false by the plaintiff's declaration that he does not chew tobacco.

VOGEL v FELICE (Dumb Asses) 127 CA4 1006 [See: CCP 425.16; NY Times v Sullivan 376 US 254; Beilenson v Superior Court 44 CA4 944, T/AT 5/96; Beruan v French 56 CA3 825; Franklin v Dynamic 116 CA4 375, T/AT 4/04; Stolz v KSFM 30 CA4 195, T/AT 12/94]


No guarantees.
Always check current status of cases before citing them.

2005 Case Summaries

JAN: 3930 | 3931 | 3932 | 3933 | 3934 | 3935 | 3936 | 3937 | 3938 | 3939 | 3940 | 3941 | 3942 | 3943 | 3944 FEB: 3945 | 3946 | 3947 | 3948 | 3949 | 3950 | 3951 | 3952 | 3953 | 3954 | 3955 | 3956 MAR: 3957 | 3958 | 3959 | 3960 | 3961 | 3962 | 3963 | 3964 | 3965 | 3966 | 3967 | 3968 | 3969 | 3970 | 3971 | 3972 | 3973 | 3974 | 3975 | 3976 | 3977 | 3978 | 3979 APR: 3980 | 3981 | 3982 | 3983 | 3984 | 3985 | 3986 | 3987 | 3988 | 3989 | 3990 | 3991 MAY: 3992 | 3993 | 3994 | 3995 | 3996 | 3997 | 3998 | 3999 | 4000 | 4001 | 4002 | 4003 | 4004 | 4005 | 4006 | 4007 | 4008 | 4009 | 4010 | 4011 | 4012 | 4013 | 4014 | 4015 | 4016 | 4017 | 4018 | 4019 | 4020 | 4021 | 4022 | 4023 | 4024 | 4025 | 4026 | 4027 | 4028 | 4029 | 4030 JUN: 4031 | 4032 | 4033 | 4034 | 4035 | 4036 | 4037 | 4038 | 4039 | 4040 | 4041 | 4042 | 4043 | 4044 | 4045 | 4046 | 4047 | 4048 | 4049 | 4050 JUL: 4051 | 4052 | 4053 | 4054 | 4055 | 4056 | 4057 | 4058 | 4059 | 4060 | 4061 | 4062 | 4063 | 4064 | 4065 | 4066 | 4067 | 4068 | 4069 AUG: 4070 | 4071 | 4072 | 4073 | 4074 | 4075 | 4076 | 4077 | 4078 | 4079 | 4080 | 4081 | 4082 | 4083 | 4084 | 4085 | 4086 | 4087 | 4088 | 4089 | 4090 | 4091 | 4092 | 4093 SEPT: 4094 | 4095 | 4096 | 4097 | 4098 | 4099 | 4100 | 4101 | 4102 | 4103 | 4104 | 4105 | 4106 | 4107 | 4108 | 4109 NOV: 4110 | 4111 | 4112 | 4113 | 4114 | 4115 | 4116 | 4117 | 4118 | 4119 | 4120 | 4121 | 4122 DEC: 4123 | 4124 | 4125 | 4126 | 4127 | 4128 | 4129 | 4130 | 4131 | 4132 | 4133 | 4134 | 4135

1992 | 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 | 1998 | 1999 | 2000
2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008

Welcome Page | Index and Search | Case Summaries | Index of Citation Lists
Repairing Our Broken English | Curriculum Vitae | Sample Complimentary Tape | Membership | MCLE

ADVANCE TAPES
P.O. Box 237
The Sea Ranch, CA 95497
Phone: 1-800-564-2382
Fax: 1-800-900-4747
Email info@advance-tapes.com

This web site constructed and maintained by Cristalen
Copyright by Steven Finz ©1992 - 2008
All rights reserved