ISSUE PRECLUSION

Res judicata and collateral estoppel may each have the effect of preventing consideration of an issue that has already been litigated and decided by a court. Although they are separate concepts, even courts sometimes have difficulty telling them apart. For that reason, it may be helpful to regard both as forms of issue preclusion. The following cases considered whether previous determination of an issue prevented further consideration of an identical or similar issue in a subsequent matter. In some, the court correctly or incorrectly used the term "res judicata," while in others it used the term "collateral estoppel." In many, the court used the phrase "issue preclusion" or words to that effect.

VICTA v MERLE NORMAN 19 CA4 454
BRANSON v SUNDIAMOND 24 CA4 327
SCHULTZ v HARNEY 27 CA4 1611
ABELSON v NAT'L UNION 28 CA4 776
WESTERN v YAMAMOTO 29 CA4 1474
AMEDEO v BAKARA 29 CA4 1828
CASTRO v HIGAKI 31 CA4 350
HENRY v CLIFFORD 32 CA4 315
ROSSE v DeSOTO 34 CA4 1047
BELL v SHINE 36 CA4 1011
McDANIEL v BOARD OF EDUCATION 44 CA4 1618
CHILDREN'S HOSP v SEDGWICK 45 CA4 1780
LUCAS v COUNTY 47 CA4 277
KNOWLES v TEHACHAPI VLY HOSP 49 CA4 1083
MARTIN v COUNTY 51 CA4 688
YOUNAN v CARUSO 51 CA4 401
READY v WCAB 53 CA4 147
WINDSOR v CITATION 54 CA4 547
ACUNA v REGENTS 56 CA4 639
SCHAEFER/KARPF v CNA 64 CA4 1306
OLD REPUBLIC v SUPERIOR COURT 66 CA4 128
WRIGHT v RIPLEY 65 CA4 1189
SABEK v ENGELHARD 65 CA4 992
KELLY v VONS 67 CA4 1329
ROCHIN v JOHNSON MFG 67 CA4 1228
US GOLF ASSN v ARROYO 69 CA4 607
SMITH v GOLDEN EAGLE 69 CA4 1371
McCUTCHEN v CITY OF MONTCLAIR 73 CA4 1138
VANDENBERG v SUPERIOR COURT 21 C4 815
BRINTON v BANKERS 76 CA4 550
BUTCHER v TRUCK INS EXCH 77 CA4 1442
BALASUBRAMANIAN v SD COMM COLL DIST 80 CA4 977
RICE v CROW 81 CA4 725
COUNTY OF LA v SUPERIOR COURT 82 CA4 819
JOHNSON v SIEGEL 84 CA4 1087
CAMARGO v CA PORTLAND 86 CA4 995
LAM v KY NGO 91 CA4 892
CASTILLO v CITY OF LA 92 CA4 477
FLEISHMAN v SUPERIOR COURT 102 CA4 350
SWAT-FAME v GOLDSTEIN 101 CA4 613
YU v SIGNET BANK 103 CA4 298
WHITE v LIEBERMAN 103 CA4 210
HILLENBRAND v INA 104 CA4 784
CITY OF SIMI VALLEY v SUPERIOR COURT 111 CA4 1077
SLANEY v RANGER INS 115 CA4 306
HUNTINGDON v STOP HUNTINGDON 129 CA4 1228
LEVINE v HIGASHI 131 CA4 566
PEREZTORRES v STATE 2005 CalAppLEX 1340
P0017 FRANKLIN v 7-ELEVEN 85 CA4 1168
P0138 LA POLICE v CITY OF LA 93 CA4 607
P0148 RYAN v CA INTERSCHOLASTIC 94 CA4 1033
P0149 BENASRA v MITCHELL 96 CA4 96
GRINHAM v FIELDER 99 CA4 1049
RISAM v COUNTY OF LA 99 CA4 412
GARCIA v REHRIG 99 CA4 869
GROVES v PETERSON 100 CA4 659
MYCOGEN v MONSANTO 28 C4 888
CARRETTI v ITALPAST 101 CA4 1236
DAWSON v TOLEDANO 109 CA4 387
AMIN v KHAZINDAR 112 CA4 582
EVEREST v McNEIL 114 CA4 411
LISKA v ARNS LAW FIRM 117 CA4 275
CUEVAS v TRULINE 118 CA4 56
KILROY v STATE 119 CA4 140
PITZEN v SUPERIOR COURT 120 CA4 1374
FRIEDMAN v NORCAL MUT 120 CA4 17
ALLIED v DIEDE 127 CA4 150
ROOS v RED 130 CA4 870
KRISTINE H v LISA R 37 C4 156
RODGERS v SARGENT 136 CA4 82
LINCOLN PROPERTY CO v TRAVELERS 137 CA4 905
HERNANDEZ v CITY OF POMONA 138 CA4 506
TAYLOR v ROSEVILLE TOYOTA 138 CA4 994
PITTS v CITY 138 CA4 853
MOONEY v CASPARI 138 CA4 704
GOTTLIEB v KEST 141 CA4 110
JOGANI v JOGANI 141 CA4 158
ALVAREZ v MAY DEPARTMENT STORES 143 CA4 1223
BORDER BUSINESS PARK v CITY OF SD 142 CA4 1538
HERNANDEZ v CITY OF POMONA 145 CA4 701
HILTON K v GREENBAUM 144 CA4 1406
BOSTICK v FLEX EQUIPMENT 147 CA4 80
KEMP v TITAN 146 CA4 1474
STATE BD OF CHIROPRACTIC v SUPERIOR COURT 148 CA4 142
MACHADO v SUPERIOR COURT 148 CA4 875
BOEKEN v PHILIP MORRIS 159 CA4 1391
ZEVNIK v SUPERIOR COURT 159 CA4 76
NOBLE v DRAPER 160 CA4 1
BURDETTE v CARRIER CORP 158 CA4 1668
FERRARO v CAMARLINGHI 161 CA4 509
CALIFORNIA LOGISTICS v STATE 161 CA4 242

Back to the Index of Citation Lists

Welcome Page | Index and Search | Case Summaries | Index of Citation Lists
Repairing Our Broken English | Curriculum Vitae | Sample Complimentary Tape | Membership | MCLE

ADVANCE TAPES
P.O. Box 237
The Sea Ranch, CA 95497
Phone: 1-800-564-2382
Fax: (707) 785-3009
Email info@advance-tapes.com

This web site constructed and maintained by Cristalen
Copyright by Steven Finz ©1992 - 2008
All rights reserved