PRIVETTE AND PECULIAR RISK

In 1962, the California Supreme Court held, in Woolen, that, under the doctrine of peculiar risk, an employee of an independent contractor protected by Workers Compensation could maintain, for a job-related injury, a tort action against the landowner or general contractor who employed the independent contractor. In 1993, in Privette, the Court overruled its holding in Woolen. Since then, several Court of Appeal and Supreme Court decisions have determined the extent of Privette's application. The following citations are relevant to this question:

Woolen v. Aerojet 57 C2 407

Privette v Superior Court 5 C4 689
Toland v Sunland 18 C4 253
Camargo v Tjaarda 25 C4 1235
McKown v Wal-Mart 27 C4 219
Hooker v Dep't of Trans 27 C4 198

Yanez v US (9th Cir) 63 F3 870

Srithong v Total 23 CA4 721
Owens v GiannettaHeinrich (Disapproved) 23 CA4 1662
Smith v ACandS 31 CA4 77
Doney v TRW 33 CA4 245
Whitford v Swinerton 34 CA4 1054
Felmlee v Falcon 36 CA4 1032
Fire Ins. Exchange v American States 39 CA4 653
Orosco v Sun-Diamond 51 CA4 1659
Lopez v University Partners 54 CA4 1117
Redfeather v Chevron 57 CA4 702
Grahn v Tosco 58 CA4 1373
Zamudio v City & Cty of SF 70 CA4 445
Kinney v CSB Construction 87 CA4 28
Villafana v Camco 91 CA4 189
Ray v Silverado 98 CA4 1112
Lopez v CGM Development 101 CA4 430
Park v Burlington 108 CA4 595
Sheeler v Greystone 113 CA4 908
Biles v Exxon Mobil 124 CA4 1315
Bell v Agee Construction 125 CA4 453
BROWNE v TURNER CONSTRUCTION 127 CA4 1334
BARCLAY v LANGE 129 CA4 281
RUIZ v WEISSKER 130 CA4 52
TILLEY v CZ MASTER ASS'N 131 CA4 464
KINSMAN v UNOCAL 37 C4 659
Michael v Denbeste 137 CA4 1082
EVARD v SO CAL EDISON 153 CA4 137
MILLARD v BIOSOURCES 156 CA4 1338

Back to the Index of Citation Lists

Welcome Page | Index and Search | Case Summaries | Index of Citation Lists
Repairing Our Broken English | Curriculum Vitae | Sample Complimentary Tape | Membership | MCLE

ADVANCE TAPES
P.O. Box 237
The Sea Ranch, CA 95497
Phone: 1-800-564-2382
Fax: (707) 785-3009
Email info@advance-tapes.com

This web site constructed and maintained by Cristalen
Copyright by Steven Finz ©1992 - 2008
All rights reserved